• Skip to content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
Lifeway Research

Lifeway Research

Enlightening today’s church with relevant research and insights

  • Research
  • Insights
  • Resource Library
  • Fast Facts
  • Search

How Can Churches Successfully Navigate Leadership Transitions?

Insights| Church Life & Ministry | Sep 13, 2019

Cytonn Photography photo | Unsplash

By Aaron Earls

Congregations often enter a chaotic season when a pastor leaves, but new research finds planning and communication can make the transition smoother.

Planning helpful, but rare

Among practicing Christians who had experienced a senior pastor transition within the last five years, only 17% say the move was planned by the congregation and outgoing pastor, according to Barna.

Most (62%) were initiated by the outgoing-pastor. Few (13%) were forced transitions brought about by sickness, death, or crisis.

When leaving the senior pastor role, most (56%) leave the congregation entirely. Fewer take on a different staff role (15%) or remain at the church as a member or lay leader (20%).

In those instances where the senior pastor moves into another leadership role within the church, those in the pews believe the move had a positive outcome.

Two-thirds of practicing Christians (67%) say a transition from senior pastor to associate pastor ended well. Around half say the senior pastor entering into a co-pastor arrangement (52%) or taking on a lay leadership position (51%) was a positive move.

Fewer (42%) say it was positive for the pastor to step down but continue to attend as a member of the church.

A quarter of Christians (25%) believe the pastor leaving the congregation completely had a positive outcome, with 71% saying it went negatively.

In most cases of a leadership transition, the senior pastor leaves the church entirely. During forced transitions, 69% of pastors leave the church. The same is true of 61% of pastor-initiated moves.

Among, planned transitions, however, 40% of pastors leave. Around half (52%) stay on in some capacity.

Barna’s research found that planned transitions are often completely in a shorter time, which appears to be a factor in positive outcomes.

See also  What if My Calling Causes My Kids Pain?

“Successful leadership requires careful planning,” said David Kinnaman, president of Barna Group. “Planned departures go more smoothly, while forced or unplanned transitions are worse on multiple outcomes.”

More communication needed

In addition to planning, churchgoers believe the transition process would go better if church leaders communicated more.

According to Barna’s report, “regardless of the type of leadership transition and other factors surrounding it, communication emerged as a key to success for all parties involved.”

Yet only half of churchgoers (50%) strongly agree their church communicated clearly on a plan and process for succession.

Fewer than one-third of churchgoers (31%) say they felt the congregation had a high degree of input in the succession process.

Churchgoers who feel their church communicated about the transition and the eventual replacement were more likely to say the process went smoothly and more likely to say there was a positive outcome.

According to Kinnaman, churches should focus on long-term planning with regular, effective communication to their churchgoers to help times of transition go well and end well.

“Strong communication can cover a multitude of successions sins,” said Kinnaman, “but a ‘make-it-up-as-we-go’ approach simply has less of a chance of going smoothly, and often fails to find time and intention for other steps that improve a transition.”

AARON EARLS (@WardrobeDoor) is online editor of Facts & Trends.

Dig Deeper at Lifeway.com

Empowering Leadership: How a Leadership Development Culture Builds Better Leaders Faster

Aubrey Malphurs

FIND OUT MORE

Related posts:

Churchgoers Proud of Church’s COVID-19 Response U.S. Churchgoers Say They’ll Return Post-COVID watch clock end times Bible pastors researchWhat Do Pastors Believe About the End Times? What Do Pastors Believe About the Book of Revelation?

Primary Sidebar

Follow Us On…

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Popular

  • Pastors Have Clarity on Same-Sex Marriage, Not the Role of LGBTQ+ People in Churches
  • 7 in 10 Women Who Have Had an Abortion Identify as a Christian
  • 7 Reasons to Praise the Lord
    praise
  • Most Popular Sermon Passages, Topics in 2021

Join the Lifeway Research Newsletter

Lifeway Research: Enlightening Today’s Church with Relevant Insights.

Signup for email updates on our church and culture research.

Sign Up

Leader Resources

Bible
Clip Art
Classics
Clip Art
Current Events
Clip Art
Discipleship
Clip Art
Pastoral Ministy
Clip Art
Theology
Clip Art
VIEW ALL RESOURCES
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Custom Research
  • Resource Library
  • Search

Copyright © 2022 · Lifeway Research, a ministry of Lifeway Christian Resources